Wednesday, 30 November 2016

Math Fair - Post Thoughts

The SNAP fair was a lot of fun. It was most heartening to see students be so excited. I think the main takeaway from it for me was the reminder that students want to share knowledge with you in a judgment-free environment.

Another great point was seeing all the creative stories and artefacts the students made for their exhibits, which just goes to show that adding an element of creativity to mathematics does not diminish it or make it less significant, but allows for students to personalize it and connect with it in a way they might not otherwise.

My favourite moment was when a pair of students asked me if I wanted to hear the short version or the long version of their problem in such a way that they felt as if the long version might be considered silly. I told them that they had put the effort for the long version, so I wanted to hear it, and their faces just lit up. It almost made me wish I had gone into the elementary program... almost.

I will be using this creative aspect more in my classrooms. I like the idea of having students create word problems of their own after solving some problems. It forces them to think critically of how the language, symbology and function of mathematics connect (useful for ELL and non-ELL learners), and potentially boosts their interest.

The Keynote Speaker at the Math Conference this year, Fawn Nguyen, said that instead of giving students straightforward word problems, she would challenge them to think about what the numbers mean. For example, instead of saying "the velocity of A is 30 kph and B is 50 kph, what is the average speed?" she would ask, "The velocity of A is 30 kph and B is 50 kph. What does (30+50)/2 tell us? What does 50-30 tell us?" Her idea was that this makes students think critically rather than passively about mathematics. I feel that this idea is connected with the one of the math fair.

As for problems, I could think of two. Firstly, because of the layout of the fair, some students were going to get a lot of attention because they were in highly-visible and -visited areas, while others were hidden away in nooks, and were thus more ignored. For children, any sense of injustice feels great and discouraging, and this is something that needs to be carefully considered. Perhaps a map should be given to people to know where the different students are.

A second problem was the fact that some of the students did not have a clear understanding of the problem they were giving. While it is gratifying for a student to feel like they did a job well done, it can be demoralising to feel like you have "failed". Perhaps this is a "teachable moment" - an opportunity for a teacher to instil in their students the importance of preparation and the idea that we learn from our mistakes. However, that would require the teachers to know about it in the first place, and with the layout of the fair being what it is, it would be impossible for a teacher to see everything. I wonder what others think about this.


2 comments:

  1. Very thoughtful and generative post, Ali -- thank you!

    ReplyDelete
  2. Great to connect the math fair with Fawn Nguyen's keynote talk too.

    ReplyDelete