Wednesday, 28 September 2016

Riddles



THE FIRST RIDDLE

A fiddler and his wife
A piper and his mother
Ate 3 cakes, 3 half-cakes 
and 3/4 of another

There are really two ambiguous points in this riddle.

The first, as the clue tells us, regards the relationship between the characters, and thus their number. There may very well be four characters in total (fiddler, fiddler's wife, piper, piper's mother). However, some of these words may refer to the same person. For example, the fiddler's wife may be the piper's mother - or, the fiddler and the piper may be the same person (he may be a multi-instrumentalist). Bases on the pronouns I cannot see how there are any other possibilities.

So, the first ambiguity has to do with whether there are three or four characters, which is where the riddle confuses the reader.

The second ambiguity is regarding the cakes eaten. Are the amounts of cake specified referring to how much EACH person ate, or how much was eaten IN TOTAL. Depending on which one it is, the other could very well be the question the riddle asks.

However, nothing in the riddle seems to indicate anything that could tell us anything about either the first or second ambiguity. So, to me, both options are equally valid.

THE SECOND RIDDLE

Brothers and Sisters 
Have I none
But that man's father 
Is my father's son

The key word here is "but". In logic, "but" is said to have the meaning as "and". In other words, the poem is equivalent, logically, to

Brothers and Sisters 
Have I none
And that man's father 
Is my father's son

But linguistically, the word "but" indicates a contrast or a contradiction. The second statement should be incongruous with the first, yet it is not. The riddle is asking us to solve that incongruity. Since the phrase "that man" both draws the reader's attention to an individual and yet leaves them vague, the natural question would be to ask - who is that man, or what relation is he to me (the riddler)?

p.s. I leave both riddles unanswered lest someone wants to write the solutions in the comments.

Monday, 26 September 2016

Art Project

In recreating and expanding "Kandinsky in Binary", our group was able to build both visual and musical compositions that were aesthetically pleasing and mathematically interesting. For example, while creating the base-8 grid below, many patterns emerged which are simply extensions of the properties of numbers. For example, the outer rings were uniform in the columns, while the same was true for the inner rows along the rows. In addition, the bottom-left to top-right diagonal features the same colours for both rings. Furthermore, this diagonal is also a line of symmetry - the colours of the rings are transposed across this line of symmetry.



The teacher can use these grids to ask the students why these patterns are happening. For example, the bottom-left to top-right diagonal has the same colour for both rings because they are all multiples of 9, which in base-8 is 11. The same thing happens in base-10 with multiples of number 11, as it would with the number 11 in any base.

But for me, the most important lesson this project demonstrates is how the properties of numbers are the foundation of aesthetic patterns in nature, art, and music. Students often ask why we learn mathematics and see it as a frivolous and inapplicable intellectual exercise. I could see how this very exercise could not only help them understand the concepts on a more intuitive level, but also prove to them the "reality" of the mathematics, the way an experiment can satisfy a student that a scientific theory or principle is correct. For a subject that is notorious for alienating a lot of students, that might be the most important thing of all.

Kandinsky in Binary (and other bases) by Colin Grabowski, Ali Hasan, John Hawthorne



In our project, we were given the painting Kandinsky in Binary by Marc and Marion Chamberland. The artwork represents the numbers from 0-63 in concentric circle form by first converting the numbers from decimal to binary (base-2) and then representing the binary numbers visually  by associating each circle with one digit and leaving it white for "0" and shaded for "1".

We varied the artwork by looking at other bases (base-3, -4, -6 and -8). A square grid was used for all bases, except for base-6 which was represented in a hexagon.

Power Point Presentation

In addition, the original artwork was transformed into an animated clip, and each of the rings was associated with one of the notes in the solfege scale (do re me fa sol la). The resulting animation and music, which follows the numbers from 0 to 63 and back again, is presented in the link below:

Video

Tuesday, 20 September 2016

Chess Puzzle

To solve the chess problem, my first instinct was to count from the bottom up - so starting with the smallest squares (1 x 1) and going up in size. But trying to figure out the number of 2 x 2 squares seemed daunting. It occurred to me that it made more sense to start from the top down.

Working "down" I noted that there is one 8 x 8 square, four 7 x 7 squares and nine 6 x 6 squares. The pattern that seems to emerge is one of square numbers, which seems to be confirmed by the existence of sixty-four 1 x 1 squares. It seems highly likely that the answer would be:

1 + 4 + 9 + 16 + 25 + 36 + 49 + 64 = 204

or


 which could then be expanded to any size square board by replacing 8 with n.

However, though this solution "feels" right, it isn't an actual proof.


I then thought about approaching it from a different way. When dealing with big problems I usually like to start with smaller ones and see if a pattern can emerge there. So, if we were dealing with a 1x1 square we would have, naturally, 1 square. If it was a 2x2 square, we would have 1 + 4. If it were a 3x3 square, it would be 1 + 4 + 9, and so on. Once again, the formula seems to fit, but this is still not a proof.

I was feeling both sure that I had the answer and yet frustrated that I couldn't find the proof... Then, after leaving the problem for a while and coming back to it, I reframed the question as follows:

If you have an n x n board, how many (n-1) x (n-1) squares will you have?

Well, I thought, any (n-1) x (n-1) square must occupy all but 1 row and 1 column (with one interlocking square) of the n x n square (as in the figure below). These rows and columns must be at the end of the chessboard. Thus, for there to be more than one square, you would need a unique combination of this row and column. Since there are two possibilities for placing each row (the first and last row) and two possibilities for each column (the first and last column), there are 2 x 2 = 4 possible squares.



By the same logic, when you have a (n-2) x (n-2) square, you would have a square that occupies all but two rows and two columns (see the next figure). To consider the number of possibilities, I visualized the square occupying the board and realized that the question could be interpreted as how many rows were on one side of the square (say on top of it). There could be zero, 1, or 2 of the rows. Hence there are 3 possibilities, and the same for the number of columns; thus there are 3 x 3 = 9 possibilities. Having found a logical explanation for why the square numbers come from, I am both more confident in the answer and satisfied with the formula.



This problem can teach a lot of learning skills in mathematical problem solving: breaking big problems into smaller ones, thinking visually, and re-interpreting problems (the number of squares = the number of row-column combinations).

In addition to obvious changes to the problem (such as changing the size of the grid), both the shape of the grid and the pieces searched for can be changed (for example, to 2x3 rectangles, or, if you want to get really tricky, any rectangle). Additional complexities can be added by mutilating the board. How many squares will there be if we remove one of the corners, or if we cut a square shaped hole in the middle of the board? Or even the nature of the question can change: for example, how many squares are there in the board which do not have an edge on the outer border of the chessboard? 

Monday, 19 September 2016

TPI


My TPI appears to be mostly balanced, but there were a couple of surprising elements. Mostly, I am surprised that the highest aspect is the nurturing. I would have assumed it to be transmission - coming from a positivist, scientific background, I'd assume content to trump emotion. Another interesting point is that I scored as highly as I did on social reform - a topic that doesn't automatically come up in typical math discussions. But then it occurs to me how much I care about the way math is taught (specifically, how it it taught to female students) and both of these points begin to make sense.

Thursday, 15 September 2016

PROBLEM 1



My first instinct is to factorize the numbers and to smart with the smallest one. 21 is 3 times 7, so it can be represented by the three numbers 1, 3, 7. Immediately, I realize the benefit of finding a number that can only be uniquely represented as the product of three numbers between 1 and 9. Is there any particular method of determining them, I wonder? I save this idea for now and carry on.

I check the rows to find a number that is divisible by 7. Once that is discovered finding the other two spots is academic.


The "7" makes me think of other prime numbers. The next biggest one in the grid is 5, and clearly there is only one row and one column number that are divisible by 5, so in it goes. Checking number for divisibility by 9 is also an easy task, and again only two numbers fit.


From there it is just a matter of division.

 


PROBLEM 2



I don't like unknowns, so once again I gravitate towards solving that first. Since I know all 9 numbers from 1-9 are in the grid, and the numbers outside are the products of three of them, then it follows that the product of all three "row" numbers should equal the product of all three "column" numbers should equal the product of all numbers from 1 to 9. In other words, 40 * 48 * ? = 9!

Thus the missing number is 189.

Now using the same focus on the two big primes 5 and 7, as the previous puzzle, it's clear that 7 can only fit in the top right corner, and 5 in the bottom left.



The two leftmost squares on the top row must have a product of 4. Since each number is used once, the only possible numbers are 1 and 4. Similarly, the two rightmost numbers in the last column must be 3 and 9. Taking every combination and permutation, the following numbers are possible for the remaining squares.


From there, using "brute force", I was able to find three answers.


These puzzles incorporate lots of different math skills: arithmetic, factorization, logic, certain elements of number theory. It utilizes understanding, because it isn't similar to anything else I have seen in any math textbooks or curricula. Of course, once you solve a few of them, it could then turn into a matter of fluency, as you figure out a procedure and try to follow it again and again. I could see this working for students as young as 10 and up. They could work in groups or even take it home to think about it for days. Students might not even be expected to solve it, but they could figure out important aspects and it could encourage them to ask for hints which would help them think more logically. I imagine this kind of puzzle is also good in assisting students to work out how algorithms for problems are created (a very useful concept, ESPECIALLY in computer science... he said knowingly.)

Tuesday, 13 September 2016

Dr. Skemp-love (or how I learned to stop worrying about the chain rule and love calculus)

 
Richard Skemp's paper reminds me of the time my high school calculus teacher asked us to prove the chain rule. One student offered the solution:



an answer that satisfied all the students. The teacher said this was wrong, but did not clarify why. He then showed us the correct proof in the textbook.

At the time I did not like calculus – I did not understand nor did I see any application for it in my desired career path. My goal was to pass the test, so, like many of my classmates, I memorized the proof verbatim and was satisfied with the "fraction" explanation of the chain rule, even though I “knew” it was wrong.

Nearly two decades later I revisited calculus as part of completing my requirements for the TEO program. Via self-teaching (utilizing books and online videos) I not only understood calculus, I found that it was actually one of my favourite fields. What had happened? Skemp doesn't mention testing in his paper, but my personal experience is that this is the big driver in whether students (and teachers) push for relational or instrumental understanding in their classes.

Monday, 12 September 2016

Hello World (or EDCP 342 A class, whatever). This is just a test to make sure this works. Sorry I couldn't come up with anything interesting.