Monday, 24 October 2016

PRO-D

Since I missed this posting the first time around, I guess I'll post it discussing what I did rather than what I plan on doing.

I went to two 100-minute workshops. The first was Problems, Strategies and Games that lead to Math Talk by Fred Harwood. The second was Social Justice and mathematics: Beyond the equation by Sean Chorney.

Thursday, 20 October 2016

Of Cans and Tanks



When the problem says that we are given the size of the soup can, I'm not sure if this refers to the volume of the can or the dimensions. I assume it's the latter, and will work with that. (Even if volume was given, however, the answer can be determined using the following steps plus a few more, such as evaluating the ratio of the bike's width to the tank's width).

A cylinder has two defining values: a radius and height, so if two cylinders have the same dimensions, then they have the same ratio of radius to height. Call the soup can radius and height, r and h, and assume these are given (or can be worked out). Thus, if we can work out either the radius or height of the water tank, we can get the other from the ratio, and hence the volume of the tank.

Let's call the bike's height B. The best we can do from this photo is estimate the radius of the tank by comparing it with the photo. This is a tricky task for a couple of reasons: the bike is not completely upright and the can is slightly askew. However, we can estimate that the bike's height B is a certain fraction of the tank's radius (call it R). Thus, we can work out R, from which we can work out the tank's height. From here, we can work out the volume using the formula for cylinders and whether its capacity can put out an average house fire.

To wit: I estimate that the ratio of the bike's height to the tank's radius was 15:13. Thus, the tank's radius was 13B/15. Say the bike's height was 150 cm. Thus the tank's radius was 130 cms. The height can then be worked out, since H:130 = h:r (the can's dimensions). Using measuring tape and a 10 oz can of Campbell's beef broth I discovered that dimensions are r = 3.25 and h = 10. Thus, H:130 = 10:3.25. So H = (130 x 10)/3.25 = 400 cms. Converting to meters we get radius of 1.3 and height of 4 meters.

To measure the volume we use the formula for cylinders and get pi * 1.3 * 1.3 * 4 which is roughly 21.2 cubic meters.

To measure how much water that is, we convert to gallons using the equation that 1 cubic meter equals 264.172 gallons. Thus, the can holds 21.2 * 264.172 which is approximately 5600 gallons of water. According to the website of the town of Carlise, Massachusetts, you need 25 to 30 thousand gallons to put out an average house fire. This water tank is not sufficient for that purpose.

Microteaching Feedback and Reflection


FEEDBACK FORMS:




REFLECTION

Our group took this opportunity of having multiple teachers to experiment and, as with any experiment, there were good and bad elements to it. Having fewer students per group allowed us to pay more attention to students and even forced students who were reluctant to be in class (nice role playing, guys!) to participate more than they would otherwise. On the other hand, there was some confusion among our students as to what they were doing - for example, none of them moved between tables, which I hoped they would do. I think this lesson would have worked better with a larger class and more time. Time management probably could have been better, too. Although I didn't get to see my fellow teachers, though, the feedback shows that they got good marks on preparation, presence and knowledge. I think this shows that good teachers thrive, regardless of the setup, through sheer passion and care. I hope that this is a quality I possess.

Tuesday, 18 October 2016

EDCP 342 Microteaching Lesson Plan (October 19, 2016)
BY: Ali, Jonathan, and Rashi

Course:  Apprenticeship and Workplace Mathematics 11
Unit:  Volume and Capacity
Lesson:  Volume of Prisms and Cylinders

Big Ideas:  Spatial relationships can help us describe and represent our real-world experience.
Curricular Competencies:  Develop, demonstrate, and apply conceptual understanding of mathematical ideas; Visualize to explore and illustrate mathematical concepts and relationships

Materials:  10 copies of the volume worksheet; stack of sticky notes or paper to demonstrate the the idea behind the volume formulas, realia (water bottle, tupperware), measuring tape.

Introduction  
(3 mins)
- Introduce ourselves
- Explain structure of lesson (3 table set up)
Table 1 - Theory
(12 mins)
- Jonathan responsible for reviewing definitions of volume (the amount of space an object takes up) and capacity (the amount something can hold) as well as demonstrating idea behind the calculating volume of prisms and cylinders (i.e., base area x height).
- If students are comfortable with these basic ideas then they can move to Table 2 or Table 3.
- Materials: rectangular vase, cylindrical vase, sticky note
- Examples to cover:
  1. Rectangular Prism - use vase as visual
    V = 4cm x 6cm x 10cm = 240cm^3
  2. Cylinder - use vase as visual
    V = pi x (4cm)^2 x 12cm = 603.19cm^3
  3. Triangular Base Prism - draw diagram (isosceles)
    V = ( 7.5cm x 6.0cm x (½) ) x 10.0cm = 337.50cm^3
  4. Octogonal Base Prism - draw diagram
    V = 8 x ( 30cm x 36cm x (½) ) x 60cm = 259,200cm^3
Table 2 - Practice
(12 mins)
- Rashi responsible for reviewing the difference between volume and capacity by showing a book and a container, and asking them the formula of volume of rectangular prism and cylinder that they have learnt in the theory part (table 1).
- Teacher presents handouts to students that includes calculation of:
  1. Volume of a cylinder, number of rectangular prisms that can fit in a cylinder, mass of object filled in the the cylinder and proportional reasoning for volume of cylinder
  2. Volume of a cylinder and comparison of volume to its capacity in percentage
  3. Example related to engine displacement

- Teacher walks and helps students through problems calculating volumes of rectangular prisms and cylinders
- If students get stuck they can ask questions or they can come back to Table 1 for more clarification on the Theory
- And they can go to table 3 to learn its applications in real life.
Table 3 - Application
(12 mins)
- Ali responsible for posing problem for students to do some problem solving/connecting what they have learned to everyday life
-Teacher presents to students a problem with a cylindrical and box-shaped container: which carries more water. Teacher asks students to think of as many ways as they can answer the question. Using think-pair-share, students come up with a list and then discuss with each other and teacher. Teacher makes students think about advantages and disadvantages of each method (e.g. time, ease, accuracy) and then has students solve the problem in as many ways as possible.
- If students feel they are not ready to tackle the problem, they can go back to Table 1 for more clarification on the Theory
Conclusion
(3 mins)
- Review what was covered and take questions
- Motivate next lesson on volume of square base pyramids and cones by asking students if they can see a problem with applying the theory they learned in today’s lesson

Assessment:  Students are responsible for assessing their own comprehension and moving to the tables that are most helpful / interesting to them.  


Wednesday, 5 October 2016

Monday, 3 October 2016


Puzzle




Here's a quick and short puzzle which can be answered in multiple ways, some better than others:

* An elimination tennis tournament is held for 47 players. How many tennis matches will transpire?

[Adapted from Problematical Recreations 5]

Post answers in comments.

[Answers to Rashi and Jon's puzzles were provided in their comments.]

Letters from the Future

Dear Mr. Hasan (though I suppose I can call you Ali now),

I hope you remember me. I think you probably will. I used to be in your math class about nine years ago. I was the annoying one who was always saying things like "I don't understand" and "I can't do it", usually with my head in my hands. Maybe you get a lot of students like that, I don't know. If it helps, I once broke down in your office because I didn't think I was able to understand fractions.

I remember you talked me down then and, though I didn't do well on that test, you still encouraged me afterwards. You kept trying to explain it to me and, at the same time, getting me to work on my anxiety. Your words of encouragement meant a lot to me - more than your explanations, by the way - and as you'll recall I managed to get a B by the end of the course, just enough to get into my college.

Well, I didn't end up doing anything math-related, but that's OK. I remember what you told us in class about how we didn't all have to be good at math, but that we were all capable of it. I remember what you told us about how anything we learned could be used in our lives, whether it was music or a foreign language or mathematics. Now, whenever I help my kids with their homework, I always think of that advice. I try to make their learning fun and exciting and instil in them the same sense of wonder that you tried to instil in us.

Well I hope this letter finds you well. Maybe next time I'm in Vancouver, I'll come by and visit. Maybe I can even give a talk to your class.

Love,
Persephone Q. Hasenpfeffer

* * *

Dear Mr. Hasan,

I am writing you this letter because I believe it will give me closure.

Several years ago, I was one of your students in math class, although you probably don't remember me. At the time, you didn't seem to pay me any special attention. I used to sit in the back of the class and never raised my hand. I was sitting behind a really tall student and you may not even have seen me. Either you didn't notice or didn't care that I was on my phone playing Candy Crush all the time.

The one time that you did pay attention to me was when I was acting up. I can't even remember what it was - I think I called you a name in class which got everyone laughing. Do you remember your response? You sent me right away to the principal's office. You didn't stop to find out why I was reacting that way. You didn't stop to think that you were not doing your job as a teacher. You didn't stop to think that I might have been crying out for help.

This is the part where I tell you about what I was going through and what happened after I left school, but you know what? I'm just not up to it. There was a lot going on at my home and in my head back then, and things have not been easy for me since I left. I don't know if you care. I don't suppose you think about me all these years. I guess you were more concerned with your "happy" students who were always raising their hands and asking questions.

I'm not writing to blame my problems on you. I just want you to think about what you did, so that if you are still teaching, you make changes so that if there's another student like me they don't get the same treatment.

Love and peace,
Kashkaval T. Woolywillow 



Good and Bad Teaching Experiences

While I have an easy time remembering what my maths teachers were like, I do have a bit of trouble remembering how they taught. Perhaps that is a positive reflection on them (i.e. only the really bad stand out) or a negative one (i.e. none had a lasting effect on me). Or, perhaps, this is just a reflection on my age and memory.

In any case, I do recall how poorly I did in specific maths subjects in high school, namely calculus. I have mentioned on this blog before that calculus is now one of my favourite math subjects, and I attribute my poor performance in high school to a number of issues, amongst them how I was taught. A common trait among teachers at my school was that they made assumptions about what students knew before a lesson was taught and understood after it. Often they would frame their checking in such a way so as to discourage questions (e.g. saying "That's obvious, right?" rather than "Is that clear?" or better yet, "Does anyone have any questions about that?")

Even worse, the teachers I remember would often put down students who asked questions as either being dense or inattentive. I think this is a cultural thing: In Bahrain, asking the teacher a question was like an accusation that they didn't explain the material properly the first time.

Some of my best learning experiences have occurred in the past few years where I took some online math courses. In contrast to my high school teachers, these professors were very encouraging of any queries as they saw it as a sign of intellectual curiosity and a desire to learn. I think that many of my high school teachers looked upon students with suspicion, almost as adversaries who were trying to upset the classes. And while some students fit that category, it was unfair and unhelpful for the teachers to treat the entirety of the class that way. It was clear that they wanted to just get through the class and go home, and that was not conducive to learning.

One of my biggest fears going into teaching is that I will carry on this tradition. I am extremely wary of this dichotomy: wanting to "control" the class while at the same time making it an environment of learning first. I would hope to incorporate the learning strategies that I have picked up, both from the online course teachers I knew and the UBC education program.