Dear Mr. Hasan (though I suppose I can call you Ali now),
I hope you remember me. I think you probably will. I used to be in your math class about nine years ago. I was the annoying one who was always saying things like "I don't understand" and "I can't do it", usually with my head in my hands. Maybe you get a lot of students like that, I don't know. If it helps, I once broke down in your office because I didn't think I was able to understand fractions.
I remember you talked me down then and, though I didn't do well on that test, you still encouraged me afterwards. You kept trying to explain it to me and, at the same time, getting me to work on my anxiety. Your words of encouragement meant a lot to me - more than your explanations, by the way - and as you'll recall I managed to get a B by the end of the course, just enough to get into my college.
Well, I didn't end up doing anything math-related, but that's OK. I remember what you told us in class about how we didn't all have to be good at math, but that we were all capable of it. I remember what you told us about how anything we learned could be used in our lives, whether it was music or a foreign language or mathematics. Now, whenever I help my kids with their homework, I always think of that advice. I try to make their learning fun and exciting and instil in them the same sense of wonder that you tried to instil in us.
Well I hope this letter finds you well. Maybe next time I'm in Vancouver, I'll come by and visit. Maybe I can even give a talk to your class.
Love,
Persephone Q. Hasenpfeffer
* * *
Dear Mr. Hasan,
I am writing you this letter because I believe it will give me closure.
Several years ago, I was one of your students in math class, although you probably don't remember me. At the time, you didn't seem to pay me any special attention. I used to sit in the back of the class and never raised my hand. I was sitting behind a really tall student and you may not even have seen me. Either you didn't notice or didn't care that I was on my phone playing Candy Crush all the time.
The one time that you did pay attention to me was when I was acting up. I can't even remember what it was - I think I called you a name in class which got everyone laughing. Do you remember your response? You sent me right away to the principal's office. You didn't stop to find out why I was reacting that way. You didn't stop to think that you were not doing your job as a teacher. You didn't stop to think that I might have been crying out for help.
This is the part where I tell you about what I was going through and what happened after I left school, but you know what? I'm just not up to it. There was a lot going on at my home and in my head back then, and things have not been easy for me since I left. I don't know if you care. I don't suppose you think about me all these years. I guess you were more concerned with your "happy" students who were always raising their hands and asking questions.
I'm not writing to blame my problems on you. I just want you to think about what you did, so that if you are still teaching, you make changes so that if there's another student like me they don't get the same treatment.
Love and peace,
Kashkaval T. Woolywillow