Monday, 3 October 2016

Good and Bad Teaching Experiences

While I have an easy time remembering what my maths teachers were like, I do have a bit of trouble remembering how they taught. Perhaps that is a positive reflection on them (i.e. only the really bad stand out) or a negative one (i.e. none had a lasting effect on me). Or, perhaps, this is just a reflection on my age and memory.

In any case, I do recall how poorly I did in specific maths subjects in high school, namely calculus. I have mentioned on this blog before that calculus is now one of my favourite math subjects, and I attribute my poor performance in high school to a number of issues, amongst them how I was taught. A common trait among teachers at my school was that they made assumptions about what students knew before a lesson was taught and understood after it. Often they would frame their checking in such a way so as to discourage questions (e.g. saying "That's obvious, right?" rather than "Is that clear?" or better yet, "Does anyone have any questions about that?")

Even worse, the teachers I remember would often put down students who asked questions as either being dense or inattentive. I think this is a cultural thing: In Bahrain, asking the teacher a question was like an accusation that they didn't explain the material properly the first time.

Some of my best learning experiences have occurred in the past few years where I took some online math courses. In contrast to my high school teachers, these professors were very encouraging of any queries as they saw it as a sign of intellectual curiosity and a desire to learn. I think that many of my high school teachers looked upon students with suspicion, almost as adversaries who were trying to upset the classes. And while some students fit that category, it was unfair and unhelpful for the teachers to treat the entirety of the class that way. It was clear that they wanted to just get through the class and go home, and that was not conducive to learning.

One of my biggest fears going into teaching is that I will carry on this tradition. I am extremely wary of this dichotomy: wanting to "control" the class while at the same time making it an environment of learning first. I would hope to incorporate the learning strategies that I have picked up, both from the online course teachers I knew and the UBC education program.

1 comment:

  1. Thanks Ali. It's tricky negotiating different cultural norms from two very different societies. Your experiences in high school sound tough from a Canadian point of view, but despite the intention to make schooling here more inquiry-oriented, you will still see some teachers here who discourage student curiosity and deep questions. I think it's sometimes because the teacher feels threatened or pressured in some way. I am glad that your online courses were so good! I think you're right -- that a lot of it has to do with the teachers' sense of their students either as adversaries or as collaborators.

    ReplyDelete