Wednesday, 30 November 2016

Math Fair - Post Thoughts

The SNAP fair was a lot of fun. It was most heartening to see students be so excited. I think the main takeaway from it for me was the reminder that students want to share knowledge with you in a judgment-free environment.

Another great point was seeing all the creative stories and artefacts the students made for their exhibits, which just goes to show that adding an element of creativity to mathematics does not diminish it or make it less significant, but allows for students to personalize it and connect with it in a way they might not otherwise.

My favourite moment was when a pair of students asked me if I wanted to hear the short version or the long version of their problem in such a way that they felt as if the long version might be considered silly. I told them that they had put the effort for the long version, so I wanted to hear it, and their faces just lit up. It almost made me wish I had gone into the elementary program... almost.

I will be using this creative aspect more in my classrooms. I like the idea of having students create word problems of their own after solving some problems. It forces them to think critically of how the language, symbology and function of mathematics connect (useful for ELL and non-ELL learners), and potentially boosts their interest.

The Keynote Speaker at the Math Conference this year, Fawn Nguyen, said that instead of giving students straightforward word problems, she would challenge them to think about what the numbers mean. For example, instead of saying "the velocity of A is 30 kph and B is 50 kph, what is the average speed?" she would ask, "The velocity of A is 30 kph and B is 50 kph. What does (30+50)/2 tell us? What does 50-30 tell us?" Her idea was that this makes students think critically rather than passively about mathematics. I feel that this idea is connected with the one of the math fair.

As for problems, I could think of two. Firstly, because of the layout of the fair, some students were going to get a lot of attention because they were in highly-visible and -visited areas, while others were hidden away in nooks, and were thus more ignored. For children, any sense of injustice feels great and discouraging, and this is something that needs to be carefully considered. Perhaps a map should be given to people to know where the different students are.

A second problem was the fact that some of the students did not have a clear understanding of the problem they were giving. While it is gratifying for a student to feel like they did a job well done, it can be demoralising to feel like you have "failed". Perhaps this is a "teachable moment" - an opportunity for a teacher to instil in their students the importance of preparation and the idea that we learn from our mistakes. However, that would require the teachers to know about it in the first place, and with the layout of the fair being what it is, it would be impossible for a teacher to see everything. I wonder what others think about this.


Monday, 28 November 2016

SNAP FAIR

The idea behind the Math fair, as detailed in the SNAP booklet, is outstanding. I like it a lot. Would I run such a program? Possibly when I am a full-time teacher. I would not run it at my practicum high school, though, and the reason has nothing to do with the fair idea. My practicum is held at a school which is already well-known for its academic focus, with mathematics being a particular area of excellence. In the short time that I have been at my school, I have witnessed how the school already establishes some of the ideas laid out in the booklet in their day-to-day classes. Both honours and standard math students are regularly given puzzles and asked to work on them in groups. Similarly, there are schoolwide competitions in which math puzzles are handed out. There is also a math club. I have also been present during some of the extracurricular math competitions the students take part in on their own volition.

I feel that holding a Math Fair at a school such as this would only attract those students who are already heavily involved in maths. Yes, it could be a good way to introduce other students to mathematics, but I do not like the idea of making the fair mandatory. I feel that this would be a great idea at some other schools, however.

Thursday, 24 November 2016

MATH AND SOCIAL JUSTICE

I have heard that the official toast of pure mathematicians is "Here's to pure mathematics; may it never find an application!" For most people, however, mathematics is a field that is useful only because it has applications in the real world. Even people who say that they will never use mathematics themselves would have to be incredibly dishonest to say that it has no uses whatsoever, from computing to business to engineering, and so on.

Some people seem to doubt, however, that mathematics has any personal application outside of certain professions. This is where Stocker's point that math is involved in social justice comes into play.

In this day and age, many people believe in conspiracy theories, but I often respond that there is no need for conspiracies: injustices happen in the open because people cannot see then or interpret them. Politicians and corporations use statistics and faulty logic to mislead and people are not educated enough to process this pseudo-data. For me, social justice has to do with overcoming misconceptions, because it is only through ignorance and confusion that social injustice occurs.

I have long believed that logic should be a required course for all students. There is far too much emphasis today on rhetoric and giving everyone a voice, and not enough on assessing objective truths. People need to know what is and is not valid logically, as this will affect every aspect of their lives.

Statistics are another important area because, as someone in the class mentioned (I believe it was Chris) whether you know how to use mathematics or not, it will be used on you. A recent example I can think of has to do with the US election. Certain pollsters, such as Nate Silver, stated that Donald Trump had a 30% chance of becoming president. After the election, the news channels stated that "the pundits got it wrong." This is a misunderstanding of statistics: a 30% is not insignificant. Things with a 30% chance of happening occur quite frequently (30% of the time, in fact). The problem is that this misunderstanding of statistics is being used to present a narrative that experts do not know what they are talking about and that they were trying to conspire to rig the election against Donald Trump.

Another example from the election that matters to me is the discrepancy between the winner of the popular vote and the electoral college. It's feasible that quite a lot of people (including Americans who voted) do not understand how that is possible. Nor do they understand how gerrymandering works. People are ignorant of the mathematics that is being used (and misused) to benefit certain people and disadvantage others. This is why math education is so important - without it, we can never know anything at all and just have to trust others blindly. And that has never worked.




THREE CAKES



So for the three recipes I found, I used the following conversion rates (from Google.com).

1 cup of flour = 120 grams
1 medium egg = 60 grams
1 cup of sugar = 200 grams
1 cup of milk = 250 grams
1 cup of butter = 227 grams

LEMON POUND CAKE (FOOD.COM WEB SITE)
I started with the basic pound cake, since this is theoretically the most balanced cake.


Ingredient
Amount per recipe
Weight in grams
Percentage (of five ingredients)
Flour
1.5 cups
180
24.4
Eggs
2 eggs
120
16.2
Sugar
1 cup
200
27.1
Milk
0.5 cups
125
16.9
Butter
0.5 cups
113.5
15.4

In this recipe, flour and sugar are clearly heavier than the other ingredients (which are close in weight). As Ms. Chongchitnant pointed out in class, new pound cake recipes have varied from the original equally-weighted recipe, probably to accommodate our much more pronounced taste for sweet deserts.

BATTENBERG CAKE (BBC GOODFOOD WEB SITE)

Battenberg cakes are very common in England (where I lived). You could even buy them readymade in supermarkets. I have not seen them here, so I thought it would be interesting to bring it up. It is also helpful that the web site mostly used weights. It is also notable for having no milk.

Ingredient
Amount per recipe
Weight in grams
Percentage (of five ingredients)
Flour

140
20.9
Eggs
3 eggs
180
26.9
Sugar
175
26.1
Milk


0
Butter
113.5
26.1

Milk notwithstanding, this recipe is quite balanced. The amount of flour is less than the other ingredients, however.

DEVIL'S FOOD CAKE (MARTHA STEWART)

When I was a child, I used to love Devil's Food Cake. That's why I picked it. I wish I had some right now.

Ingredient
Amount per recipe
Weight in grams
Percentage (of five ingredients)
Flour
3 cups
360
21.9
Eggs
4 eggs
240
14.6
Sugar
2.25 cup
450
27.4
Milk
1 cup
250
15.2
Butter
1.5 cups
340.5
20.8
As with the pound cake, the sugar weight is much higher than the other ingredients. Flour and butter are also high, while milk and eggs are lower. Perhaps this is a regional thing - as the British recipe has more egg (but no milk).

Wednesday, 23 November 2016

Math and Social Justice

I have heard that the official toast of pure mathematicians is "Here's to pure mathematics; may it never find an application!" For most people, however, mathematics is a field that is useful only because it has applications in the real world. Even people who say that they will never use mathematics themselves would have to be incredibly dishonest to say that it has no uses whatsoever, from computing to business to engineering, and so on.

Some people seem to doubt, however, that mathematics has any personal application outside of certain professions. This is where Stocker's point that math is involved in social justice comes into play.

In this day and age, many people believe in conspiracy theories, but I often respond that there is no need for conspiracies: injustices happen in the open because people cannot see then or interpret them. Politicians and corporations use statistics and faulty logic to mislead and people are not educated enough to process this pseudo-data. For me, social justice has to do with overcoming misconceptions, because it is only through ignorance and confusion that social injustice occurs.

I have long believed that logic should be a required course for all students. There is far too much emphasis today on rhetoric and giving everyone a voice, and not enough on assessing objective truths. People need to know what is and is not valid logically, as this will affect every aspect of their lives.

Statistics are another important area because, as someone in the class mentioned (I believe it was Chris) whether you know how to use mathematics or not, it will be used on you. A recent example I can think of has to do with the US election. Certain pollsters, such as Nate Silver, stated that Donald Trump had a 30% chance of becoming president. After the election, the news channels stated that "the pundits got it wrong." This is a misunderstanding of statistics: a 30% is not insignificant. Things with a 30% chance of happening occur quite frequently (30% of the time, in fact). The problem is that this misunderstanding of statistics is being used to present a narrative that experts do not know what they are talking about and that they were trying to conspire to rig the election against Donald Trump.

Another example from the election that matters to me is the discrepancy between the winner of the popular vote and the electoral college. It's feasible that quite a lot of people (including Americans who voted) do not understand how that is possible. Nor do they understand how gerrymandering works. People are ignorant of the mathematics that is being used (and misused) to benefit certain people and disadvantage others. This is why math education is so important - without it, we can never know anything at all and just have to trust others blindly. And that has never worked.



Tuesday, 15 November 2016

Arbitrary and Necessary

According to Hewitt, "arbitrary" refers to ideas that are only true because of convention and cannot be learnt intuitively, while "necessary" are ones that can be understood intuitively (by some people). For any lesson, a teacher can imagine themselves as someone who has never come across this material before and see if they can figure it out by themselves. For example, a teacher asked to draw a Venn Diagram… there is no way someone could understand what the symbols of union and intersection mean. On the other hand, they would be able to understand what unions and intersections work, or how the number of elements in the union of two sets does not necessarily equal the sum of the number of two elements (and so forth).

When I learned math in school, I was always more interested in understanding the concepts than the conventions, and in my observation of students in my short practicum, there are many students who share that attitude. Specifically, many international students might be used to different conventions (for example, following data from right to left rather than left to right, as is the case with Arabic or Hebrew speakers' or using different symbols; or even using different methods for doing basic mathematical operations, such as multiplication).

The problem - for me - becomes one of trying to teach the material in a way that the students understand and trying to assess whether the students understood it. Without the "arbitrary" bits, the latter cannot be done. But in essence, it is an unfair way of assessing.

In my opinion, the ability to use or not use these methods comes back - as does so much we have discussed in our studies - with how assessment is done; and I worry that there isn't enough freedom for teachers to determine that.

Monday, 14 November 2016

Things that Surprised Me During the Short Practicum


* How impressive (and even intimidating) the UBC label was to these students.

* How much some of the students (particularly grade 8s) wanted to impress me with their knowledge and understanding.

* How small some of the students were.

* That teachers were not overly concerned with filling up the class time with content.

* That some of the students were averse to doing any pair or group work.

* That low-level ELL learners were often placed in high-level classes (and that most of the teachers did not know how to accommodate for that).

* That a good proportion of international students are here alone without their parents - in some cases, without any family members at all.

* The prevalence of junk food - often being promoted by the school itself.

* How "politically incorrect" many of the students were.