I have heard that the official toast of pure mathematicians is "Here's to pure mathematics; may it never find an application!" For most people, however, mathematics is a field that is useful only because it has applications in the real world. Even people who say that they will never use mathematics themselves would have to be incredibly dishonest to say that it has no uses whatsoever, from computing to business to engineering, and so on.
Some people seem to doubt, however, that mathematics has any personal application outside of certain professions. This is where Stocker's point that math is involved in social justice comes into play.
In this day and age, many people believe in conspiracy theories, but I often respond that there is no need for conspiracies: injustices happen in the open because people cannot see then or interpret them. Politicians and corporations use statistics and faulty logic to mislead and people are not educated enough to process this pseudo-data. For me, social justice has to do with overcoming misconceptions, because it is only through ignorance and confusion that social injustice occurs.
I have long believed that logic should be a required course for all students. There is far too much emphasis today on rhetoric and giving everyone a voice, and not enough on assessing objective truths. People need to know what is and is not valid logically, as this will affect every aspect of their lives.
Statistics are another important area because, as someone in the class mentioned (I believe it was Chris) whether you know how to use mathematics or not, it will be used on you. A recent example I can think of has to do with the US election. Certain pollsters, such as Nate Silver, stated that Donald Trump had a 30% chance of becoming president. After the election, the news channels stated that "the pundits got it wrong." This is a misunderstanding of statistics: a 30% is not insignificant. Things with a 30% chance of happening occur quite frequently (30% of the time, in fact). The problem is that this misunderstanding of statistics is being used to present a narrative that experts do not know what they are talking about and that they were trying to conspire to rig the election against Donald Trump.
Another example from the election that matters to me is the discrepancy between the winner of the popular vote and the electoral college. It's feasible that quite a lot of people (including Americans who voted) do not understand how that is possible. Nor do they understand how gerrymandering works. People are ignorant of the mathematics that is being used (and misused) to benefit certain people and disadvantage others. This is why math education is so important - without it, we can never know anything at all and just have to trust others blindly. And that has never worked.
Good commentary on this topic generally, Ali, and it's refreshing to see your sense of people's reasonableness, given that they understand the mathematics/ statistics.
ReplyDeleteI would have liked to see more connection to Stocker's writing and examples here though!