I found that using Geogebra was extremely helpful not only in proving certain theorems, but also in visualizing what exactly we were trying to show. In the example that our group had, we were tasked with showing that for any two radii of a circle, their tangent lines (if they converge) will meet at a point equidistant to the points on the circle's perimeter that meet the radii.
That is hard to visualize. In fact, that was hard for me to describe in words. As I said in class, geometry is, in essence, a visual form of mathematics and a lot of what we have done is transform it into a different non-visual mathematics. That is definitely a powerful tool, but it should not come at the expense of the visual one.
To go back to our example, it was easy to see that this theorem was probably true and I think it would satisfy most high school students (and "friends", to use Mason's terminology). Would it satisfy a skeptic, probably not, which is why you would need an algebraic proof.
That is hard to visualize. In fact, that was hard for me to describe in words. As I said in class, geometry is, in essence, a visual form of mathematics and a lot of what we have done is transform it into a different non-visual mathematics. That is definitely a powerful tool, but it should not come at the expense of the visual one.
To go back to our example, it was easy to see that this theorem was probably true and I think it would satisfy most high school students (and "friends", to use Mason's terminology). Would it satisfy a skeptic, probably not, which is why you would need an algebraic proof.
But what I found from looking at the drawing we had made was that the proof for this theorem was not too hard. The quadrilateral ABEC is formed from the radii and tangent lines. Since all radii of a circle have the same length, then the triangle ABC is isosceles. Thus the angles ACB and ABC are equal, but since the angles ABE and ACE are also equal, then the angle CBE and BCE are equal, and thus the triangle CBE is also an isosceles. Hence, BE and CE have the same length.
This proof seemed more obvious to me, I think, because I was allowed to use this tool. It truly gives you a "sense" of how these things relate.
This whole experience has brought to mind something I saw when I was 10 or so: it was a visual demonstration of the fact that a triangle's angles always sum up to 180 degrees. The angles of several triangles were cut off and placed together and they formed a perfect semicircle. At the time, I remember not being able to understand how this worked - it didn't satisfy me as a proof. I was much more willing to accept the fact that the sum was equal to 180 as an axiom.
However, one of the great things about this tool is that when you create a triangle and move the edges around to create different angles, you once again get a "sense" of how this will affect the different angles (increasing some and reducing others).
Compare that with this proof that I found online. I zoned out after the second or third line.
So, do deductive proofs convince? YES... for a certain type of person. But I think that for most people, hearing these proofs is no different than reading a treatise by Nietzsche or Foucalt or something as obtuse.
So, in my class I would definitely use both. I would start with the dynamic "proof" and then, towards the end of the class, after the concept has been absorbed, I would give the deductive proof. I would not, I should add, ever assess whether students know the proof to any theorem as, from my experience, this is something students memorize by rote.
Lovely! Thanks for this very thoughtful and thought-provoking post, Ali. It's so interesting that working in dynamic geometry software made both the theorem and proof so much more clear and intuitive (and, well, geometric!)
ReplyDelete