According to Hewitt, "arbitrary" refers to ideas that are only true because of convention and cannot be learnt intuitively, while "necessary" are ones that can be understood intuitively (by some people). For any lesson, a teacher can imagine themselves as someone who has never come across this material before and see if they can figure it out by themselves. For example, a teacher asked to draw a Venn Diagram… there is no way someone could understand what the symbols of union and intersection mean. On the other hand, they would be able to understand what unions and intersections work, or how the number of elements in the union of two sets does not necessarily equal the sum of the number of two elements (and so forth).
When I learned math in school, I was always more interested in understanding the concepts than the conventions, and in my observation of students in my short practicum, there are many students who share that attitude. Specifically, many international students might be used to different conventions (for example, following data from right to left rather than left to right, as is the case with Arabic or Hebrew speakers' or using different symbols; or even using different methods for doing basic mathematical operations, such as multiplication).
The problem - for me - becomes one of trying to teach the material in a way that the students understand and trying to assess whether the students understood it. Without the "arbitrary" bits, the latter cannot be done. But in essence, it is an unfair way of assessing.
In my opinion, the ability to use or not use these methods comes back - as does so much we have discussed in our studies - with how assessment is done; and I worry that there isn't enough freedom for teachers to determine that.
When I learned math in school, I was always more interested in understanding the concepts than the conventions, and in my observation of students in my short practicum, there are many students who share that attitude. Specifically, many international students might be used to different conventions (for example, following data from right to left rather than left to right, as is the case with Arabic or Hebrew speakers' or using different symbols; or even using different methods for doing basic mathematical operations, such as multiplication).
The problem - for me - becomes one of trying to teach the material in a way that the students understand and trying to assess whether the students understood it. Without the "arbitrary" bits, the latter cannot be done. But in essence, it is an unfair way of assessing.
In my opinion, the ability to use or not use these methods comes back - as does so much we have discussed in our studies - with how assessment is done; and I worry that there isn't enough freedom for teachers to determine that.
First -- Congratulations again, Ali! And thanks for keeping up with assignments for class, even when you must be very busy with the most important work of caring for your family and new little one.
ReplyDeleteVery thoughtful commentary on this article. I really appreciate your understanding of the true arbitrariness of mathematical/ cultural conventions . (Some who haven't had cross-cultural experiences may not truly understand this, but it is very important to know that different kinds of notation, algorithms, etc. can be equally valid mathematically). I think you'll find that there is little standardized testing in BC schools, so teachers do have a fair bit of leeway in choosing what to emphasize in our own lessons and units of work.