Richard
Skemp's paper reminds me of the time my high school calculus teacher
asked us to prove the chain rule. One student offered the solution:
an
answer that satisfied all the students. The teacher said this was
wrong, but did not clarify why. He then showed us the correct proof
in the textbook.
At
the time I did not like calculus – I did not understand nor did I
see any application for it in my desired career path. My goal was to
pass the test, so, like many of my classmates, I memorized the proof
verbatim and was satisfied with the "fraction" explanation of the chain rule, even though
I “knew” it was wrong.
Nearly
two decades later I revisited calculus as part of completing my
requirements for the TEO program. Via self-teaching (utilizing books
and online videos) I not only understood calculus, I found that it
was actually one of my favourite fields. What had happened? Skemp
doesn't mention testing in his paper, but my personal experience is
that this is the big driver in whether students (and teachers) push
for relational or instrumental understanding in their classes.
Very interesting! I would like to hear more about how and why your feelings about calculus changed over time, and what your thoughts are on testing and assessment.
ReplyDeleteAs I learned calculus on my own, I began to see not only the application of it, but also the elegance. It's really a truly clever idea that solves one specific problem, which through incremental improvements by numerous geniuses has been expanded to solve several problems. Last year I took an Ordinary Differential Equations course and that was filled with extremely clever solutions to problems that would otherwise require brute force calculations. There's a certain beauty to it.
ReplyDeleteAs for testing, I waver between thinking of it as a "necessary evil" and an "overused tool".
Thanks Ali! Interesting comments. I have also come to love the big ideas of calculus -- but sometimes wonder why it is seen by so many as the ultimate culmination of mathematical knowledge!
ReplyDelete